Ah, popularity! Some or many of you may've heard that there'd be an ep of CSI:NY featuring Second Life, titled "Down the Rabbit Hole". It aired yesterday, and while I wasn't directly involved with the internal machinimations at Linden Lab to make it possible, my respects go to my fellow Lindens and Electric Sheep Company personnel who were — and I got to enjoy watching the episode as a (pretty much) casual bystander, curled up on the couch with my wife JennifeRavenelle.
What follows are some scattershot ruminations of "Down the Rabbit Hole" in no particular order; they are to be taken as my opinion only:
- HOLY CRAP CSI:NY's theme song is "Baba O'Riley", often mistitled as "Teenage Wasteland" due to the lyrics (and presumed memorability). My younger bro earlier pointed this out to me after I showed him a certain Whitest Kids clip, so I wasn't totally surprised, but it's just so go-get-'em! The arps in the song make me smile lots.
- The "use the arrow keys to move" bit cracked me up, just because I've said that so many times to newcomers. So did the whole prompting to customize your avatar with a skin and all that, so ya don't come off like a n00b! How many of us can relate to that??
- Jen cracked me up when she joked that the motive for the murder was the stealing of a camping chair. And yeah, we saw it coming — the parallel between those mannequins and avatars.
- I understand dramatization for the sake of slickly moving the storyline along, but ohhhh gosh I do wish SL's Appearance mode for customizing your avatars worked as fast as it did in the show. /me isn't fond of waiting for texture rebakes.
- Gary Sinise looks like a shark when he smiles really wide. I didn't see him do that in this ep, but I've enjoyed a lot of movies he's been in, particularly as Lt. Dan in Forrest Gump.
- I wish more of the SL User Interface had been shown. Even displaying bits of the OnRez viewer might've helped psychologically make a transition from the show to inworld, should someone watch CSI:NY then want to try Second Life out (heyyyy I'm all for that!).
- NO, virii can't come through Second Life and shut down your whole computer in the manner portrayed. I just about slapped my forehead because I know it's caused a certain degree of support load and Live Help (further back) via questions like, "Can a script contain a virus that erases my hard drive?" Empathically, NO. For the not-so-tech-inclined, please take the show for what it is — entertainment! — and again, certain things were stylized at the sake of realism. (Understandable, I'm not stringent about it.)
- I really liked hearing mentions of "Second Life" in the show, instead of trying to pass it off as something else. The word "metaverse" even got put in. I reckon I even heard mention of "Linden dollars" at one point… someone please confirm?
- Very amusing to see the CSI crew obtain all manner of personal info without going through Linden Lab first… it's faster than going through the legal system in the space of an hour, that's for sure. But they could've shown some actual Lindens assisting in the investigation. =)
- In some earlier inworld scenes, I distinctly saw WindLight (which I am Product Manager for) used. In later ones, I saw the "old skool skies". So it looks like part of it was filmed out of order? I don't know. If you have facts, please fill me in! I'm curious.
- SPOILER… that Trophy Hall shown near the end was very, very reminiscent of the venerable schizophrenia simulator by Nash Baldwin & Co. which I first visited in 2004. ESPECIALLY the faces going all dead-like, the moaning sounds, and the blood dripping down. I bet other oldbies caught on to this connection too.
- The sculptie rabbit with the glazed-over (stoned?) eyes was a hoot to watch. He isn't looking so happy here…
- Fun superimposition of the voice "radio waves" atop avatar heads. Good timing that we did get audio voice chat in SL, eh?
- Even more fun to see all the gadgetry they bandied about, including the "big screen" that SL was played on. I felt a widescreen would've been more effectively epic than the 4:3-ish aspect ratio one they had, however.
- When Dt. Mac Taylor (Sinise's character) was asked about staying up all night, I initially thought that was a reference to his newfound Second Life addition. From the look on my Jennifer's face, she may've thought the same. We shared a lot of laughs throughout all this.
- The introduction of the blue furry griefer was very hilarious. And I recognized a specific Wynx Whiplash avatar, the "Tiny Wolf", in the midst of all this… colored blue a la Patchouli Woollahra (that must be one of the most difficult last names to spell)!
- The quasi-Roman battle arena was a treat to see — I wish we could, for virtually real ;), pack that many avatars into a single region. Very lively usage of animations and particle effects… kudos to who did those! *claps*
- The doll of "Johnny" reminded me of something outta Fabjectory. I don't think they had a hand (haw), but I wonder if the similarity was known and intentional.
- I think it was a pretty novel idea for someone to have plastic surgery to look more like their avatar. There's gotta already be pressure for some people to undergo procedures because they don't want to disappoint someone they've met online. If you find yourself in this situation, the best advice I can give you before you go too deep is: embrace the wholeness of your First AND Second Lives. It's dangerously isolative and psychologically unhealthy to focus on your avatar at the expense of your RL health and self-esteem. DON'T lie or even exaggerate who you are behind the monitor too, that's almost a sure path to disappointment and even anger for everyone involved. Being in love is about earnesty, and gussying yourself up to be who you really aren't — an image you won't be able to sustain longterm — attracts the wrong kinds of attention and results in lots of hurt.
Remember: Second Life is an enhancement, a layer that sits atop your First Life, not a replacement or substitute. Use your Second Life to bring out new colors, hues, tones, richness, and more that you don't normally get to express "in the flesh". For example, my wife's avatar Ravenelle is a petite China doll (I'm using that term positively), but in real life (that widespread-but-crippled term makes me cringe because it doesn't do anything to advance our perceptions and understanding of "What is real?"), Jen's a voluptuous, tall babe who looks great with my hero, Philip Rosedale. I love all of JennifeRavenelle, and that includes her looking very different from her av. I enjoy having BOTH because I'm an AND person. Or heck, take myself — I have all manner of avatars on a Torley Council and don't look a whit like most of them 'cept Torley Sr. IRL! But I celebrate them as extensions of my personality: artistic creativity on some levels, manifestations of my spirit in the digital realm on others.
- The cliffhanger ending stumped and frustrated me because it wasn't made clear that the storyline was to be continued in Second Life, or what?!! It's like, that contract assassin woman escaped down the laundry chute, the detective put his gun in there (which looked like a scene from DOOM for a sec), and then the credits roll? More clarity about getting audience participation to "solve the case" would've greatly been appreciated. But it'll be intriguing to see how many new Residents we get.
- Heh, they primarily picked green, red, and black for "Venus"… one color is near, yet so far.
I haven't been inworld much since I'm still moving in to our new home, but blessed be, Ravie took snapshots of the inworld experience! Have a looksee:
This is Torley, feeling AICNish, signing off for now! =^..^=

























About WindLight… I am just guessing but maybe machinimas with WL were planned for inclusion in the episode but later somebody decided to cut them out or to shoot them again without WL. WL is one very persuasive and a feature with strong effect so it might be disappointment for the newcomers to see the SL without it. (Nope, I am not hurying you and your team
)
About "real life"…. I have a problem with that term too… But, is there any substitute which would be a good one? Anybody have an idea?
You can use "first life" or "meatspace" (though that sounds odd too) or… "the analog viewer" heehee
About that "virus coming through your computer and shut down your machine", that entire scene confused me for a second until I realized that they weren't talking about SecondLife, that scene was drawn from Snow Crash.
In the book "calling cards" represent "local assets" that are copied to your hard drive when you hold them, they can represent something as complex as a locally run sim or something a bit more sinister. Definitely a different meaning to what calling cards are used for in SL.
Sorry to double post, but here's an old link from the last guys that tried to merge CSI with SecondLife:
http://www.plywoodcomic.com/strip50.htm
Daedalus, I do use meatspace… it's a lot of fun to see people's faces sometimes
I've always been fond of "meatspace" as well, but I like Daedalus' idea of calling it "the analog viewer". Maybe I'll start calling it the meatviewer (then again, that sounds kind of seedy….like a cable porn channel or something.)
Second Life News for October 26, 2007…
A Second Look at Second Life…A New Practicality Emerging For Virtual Reality Technologies? A few weeks ago, I was far from the first to speculate pessimism on the viability of virtual reality site Second Life as a marketer's dream. A few r…
[...] torley.com/torleys-thoughts-on-the-csiny-second-life-episode [...]
Linden currency was mentioned…….i taped it - yes with one of those ancient relics called a VCR
The ending stumped me for a sec too….all of the sudden wham- credits… Over all it was an enjoyable experience. Laughed @ the comment about "being pegged as a total noob" and "It's NOT a game" - being in a relationship with someone who doesn't get SL -I have grumbled that same line more than once, lol..
@dandellion: I've long been intrigued when movies are shot out of sequence.
@Daed: I haven't been a fan of "meatspace" since it doesn't sound as elegant as I've liked. "Analog viewer" is a first to me; I tend to spell words like that in an English way, e.g., "analogue viewer"!
@Odysseus: Good points and very observant about the Snow Crash nod! That's what confused me. I think Calling Cards as a Second Life inventory type should eventually be replaced by Friends altogether; I don't find them very useful as a means of contacting folks… does anyone?
And GOSH, Plywood was definitely ahead of its time.
@newton: Haha, "meatviewer" sounds very David Cronenberg-ian, a la Videodrome! (One of my fave movies… LONG LIVE THE NEW FLESH.)
@Shania: Aha! Thanks. Yeah, that "NOT a game"… I really am thankful that was included, since it's easy to get all too lazy/blase about classification. In time, things will change… similarly to how we don't call automobiles "horseless carriages" anymore. It'll just take gradual education until the "old ways" are transitioned from.
Hi torley, yes linden dollars was mentioned. I found the show interesting. More fun to watch the show and how they utilized SL, than it was to visit their sims in SL. I found the CSI NY sims a bit, repetitive and blah LOL (It was like looking at pretty much any basic sim in SL)
all in all it was interesting
and I especially loved the comment about it is not a game, because SL is so much more than just a "game"
as for the calling cards, dump them, make the friends list a contact list instead, and have it so we can sort them, like we can on things like msn messanger and such. Would be nice to be able to sort them in the actual list.
(I know we can sort the calling cards, but who really ever looks at them, except to mass conference all their friends?)
hehe
L$6000 exactly!
here is the link to the full episode, I'm re-watching it right now ..lol
http://alpha.cbs.com/primetime/csi_ny/
click on CSI: NY: Episode 401
I can't wait to see this episode, only another what 5 months before it hits our shores? *sigh*
Kinda puts a percentage of Second Life's users out of the loop and out of the runnings (if the episode is required viewing for solving their cases).
n-joy your falling (back) in love for as long as it lasts
was after DM's video(es) tday and I did find your piano piece
that reminded me of your "faith and devotion" to your devoted half
rare as they are and as personal as they are these moments are to enjoy in piece and to a point, solitude.
After that I was looking for Coil, you know the reminder of Throbbing Gristle… but I ended up (and settled) with Elizabeth Frazer singing this:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mFAHVIyhtb0
Amen.
Love is the weird.
… but then I thought… what's better?
There you go Bob Wyatt's Sea Song on BBC 4.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2cWq3mIp4cU
An after that, both you and everyone in the equation out there… we must be left out pretty speechless.
and then… can I avoid to slash sugar on top of sugar and direct you to bliss that… yeah, can replicate this on your well aged piano:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pMxrsL_DW1g
live here, best on EP with a nice coda
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AVmXKNhO7Mk
Matt Johnson, "Uncertain Smile".
Best love pop song ever made?
Quite possibly.
Both you enjoy.
Did anyone notice the way they teleport? I've never seen any avatar TP like that.
Wow, with all these new people flowing in, I'm going to have to step up on adding to my little Newbie Guide website.
@Rhaorth: Thanks for sharing your experiences. And I do personally agree about killing off calling cards and making the Friends list sortable — similar and expected like most popular instant messengers on the market. It *should* be easier to start an ad-hoc group chat with specific contacts!
@Pompo: Thx for the tips! nand, can you make use of that link too? (I know some sites restrict viewing to the US; and not that I approve such means, but there's always proxies and BitTorrent…)
@starcomber: Thanks for the music recs! I haven't heard Coil in a long time but my beloved and I did listen to E. Fraser on Massive Attack's "Teardrop" the other day.
@Kabalyero: Yah, that was way fancier than even particle poofers. I'd like teleporting to be presented a lot more slickly, hand-in-hand with improved stability, of course.
@CyFishy: Ooh I didn't know you had one! *checks it out via your LiveJournal*
[...] just love CSI, I get all three CSIs from a local cable channel and I think that this crossover between CSI:NY and Second Life will be good for Second Life because it will be [...]